Tuesday, November 4, 2014

That Dirty, Disgusting Picture Is Speaking Volumes About Your Political Predilections

Greg and Sybil Orman take it to the (Main) Street in Kansas. Photo from Greg Orman Facebook page.


infestations, rotting carcasses, unidentifiable gunk in the kitchen sink. How much your brain responds to disgusting images could predict whether you are liberal or conservative.

How timely, with today's Congressional midterm elections and various state races.

In a study titled, Nonpolitical Images Evoke Neural Predictors of Political Ideology published in the 30 Oct. online edition of Current Biology, an international team led by scientists from Virginia Tech has found that the strength of a person’s reaction to repulsive images can forecast their political ideology.

In what is commonly believed to be a tight Senate race in Kansas among Libertarian Randall Batson, Independent Greg Orman and Republican Pat Roberts, this could mean that if one knows the degree of repulsion that potential voters would have to such images, it would be possible to predict with a fair degree of certainly how they will vote and which candidate will emerge the victor.

Pat Roberts explaining why he would make a fine Senator from Kansas. Photo from Pat Roberts Facebook page.

“Disgusting images generate neural responses that are highly predictive of political orientation even when those neural responses don’t correspond with an individual’s conscious reaction to the images,” said lead researcher, Read Montague, a professor at the Virginia Tech Carilion School of Medicine and Research Institute. “Remarkably, we found that the brain’s response to a single disgusting image was enough to predict an individual’s political ideology.”

Well, who's most grossed out? “We proposed that conservatives, compared to liberals, have greater negativity bias, which includes both disgusting and threatening conditions in our study,” the authors wrote.

“Our finding that only disgusting pictures, especially in the animal-reminder category, differentiate conservatives from liberals might be indicative of a primacy for disgust in the pantheon of human aversions, but it is also possible that this result is due to the fact that, compared to threat, disgust is much easier to evoke with visual images on a computer screen.”

In a brain scanner, participants were shown disgusting images, such as dirty toilets and mutilated carcasses, mixed with neutral and pleasant images, such as landscapes and babies.

Afterward, the subjects took a standard political ideology inventory, answering questions about how often they discuss politics and whether they agreed or disagreed with hot-button topics such as school prayer and gay marriage.

Randall Batson hopes Kansans will respond to his simple message. Photo from Randall Batson Facebook page.

Using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), scientists from the research institute, in collaboration with researchers from University College London, Rice University, the University of Nebraska at Lincoln and Yale University – recorded brain activity of the subjects responding to the images.

Responses to disgusting images could predict, with 95 percent to 98 percent accuracy, how a person would answer questions on the political survey.

The results suggest political ideologies are mapped onto established neural responses that may have served to protect our ancestors against environmental threats, RM said. Those neural responses could be passed down family lines — it’s likely that disgust reactions are inherited.

“We pursued this research because previous work in a twin registry showed that political ideology – literally the degree to which someone is liberal or conservative – was highly heritable, almost as heritable as height,” said RM, who directs the Computational Psychiatry Unit at the research institute.

Rick Scott looks like a man getting an endorsement for another term as the governor of Florida. Photo from Rick Scott for Governor Web site.

Political scientists have a long history of putting little credence in such findings, a fact not lost on the researchers. “Despite growing evidence from various fields, including genetics, cognitive neuroscience, and psychology, many political scientists remain skeptical of research connecting biological factors with political ideology.

“We hope some of this skepticism can be alleviated from our demonstration that fMRI data, even from a single
stimulus, can serve as a strong predictor of political ideology.”

Humans are not necessarily hardwired to respond on instinct alone,” RM asserted, using height as an analogy. “Genetics predetermines height – but not fully. Nutrition, sleep, and starvation can all change someone’s ultimate height. But tall people’s children tend to be tall, and that’s a kind of starting point.

“If we can begin to understand that some automatic reactions to political issues may be simply that – reactions – then we might take the temperature down a bit in the current boiler of political discourse.”

This is counsel that may have been heeded in the race for the governorship of Florida between leading candidates, Democrat Charlie Crist and Republican incumbent Rick Scott.

The takeaway message, then, for Election Day?

Charlie Crist has pledged to serve the people as governor of Florida. Photo from Charile Crist Facebook page.

“Think, don’t just react,” RM said. “But no one needs neuroscience to know that’s a good idea.”

Ashley Wenners Herron writes for the Virginia Tech news office; Yours Truly contributed to this article.

Visit http://www.bit.ly/1yUT9Iq to read an abstract or the full article about “Nonpolitical Images Evoke Neural Predictors of Political Ideology.”


  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  2. Hello ... I appreciate your candid response, Sir, and can only hope that American women will improve, per your observations

    I do hope, however, that your boycott does not include the online lifestyle newszine, VEVLYN'S PEN.

    We appreciate your patronage. Thank you.


Creative Commons License
VEVLYN'S PEN: The Wright take on life by Vevlyn Wright is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License .
Based on a work at vevlynspen.com .
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at vevlyn1@yahoo.com .